ILoveBacons has RP on it, if I remember correctly. It's just not enforced. (Though I could be wrong. Regardless, some nice folks over there.)
Sure, but just because you allow RP doesn't make you an RP server. RP servers are RP dedicated/enforced.
I may be mistaken here, but from what I can tell, the server listing isn't just for roleplay-dedicated servers. It's just that us (all currently active dedicated roleplay servers) and ILoveBacons have been the only ones to maintain a large enough population to stay at the top of the list.
You can however search the tag "role-play". They have it for the strange reason that is "we don't enforce it but people can do it if they want so yeah".
And even when I said "But then I can fucking roleplay on a TF2 server. If they don't ban me for doing so, it doesn't make it a TF2 RP server." they /still/ keep the tag.
I think them having the tag or not isn't our business. These are public forums. I wouldn't want Bacon browsing our forums and find us discussing their practices in a negative way, and vice-versa.